The classic rule: 50% needs, 30% wants, 20% savings. Plug in your take-home pay and actual spending — this tells you where you stand in each category, not just whether the math adds up.
The product thinking behind this tool
- The key design choice: a verdict per category, not a single score. "You're over on wants by $150" is actionable; "your budget score is 72" is a horoscope. Tools should produce next actions.
- "Unaccounted for" is a feature: if needs + wants + savings don't equal take-home pay, most calculators silently ignore the gap. Surfacing it catches the estimation errors that make budgets fiction.
- The rule bends on purpose: the notes acknowledge that 50% needs is unrealistic in expensive cities. A tool that shames the user for their zip code gets abandoned; one that adapts gets kept.
- What I'd measure: the savings rate over time — the one number this tool is really about. Month-over-month retention of returning users would be the product's north star.
Why this is on my portfolio: budgeting tools are a solved category — which makes the differentiators pure product judgment: what to surface, what to forgive, what counts as success.